Retail-Marketing Twist: New Research Suggests That Low Price Guarantees Have Adverse Effects on Consumer Behavior — Reims Study Reveals Negative Consequences of “Too Good to Be True” Deal

New research from Reims Management School (RMS) reveals that consumers are often put off by promises of lowest prices that are coupled with high refund guarantees — contrary to the usual strategies of many top retailers.

Conventional marketing practice suggests the natural assumption is that consumers will choose the cheapest option when offered the same product at different prices. It is therefore up to the seller to convince the consumer that theirs is indeed the lowest price. Guarantees, coupled with a promise of reimbursement of the price difference if a cheaper option is found elsewhere, are an increasingly common method to deliver this impression.

The technique is also used to avoid "showrooming," when consumers go in-store to decide the product to buy but in the end use the Internet make the final purchase at the true "best price."

The research from Reims has found, however, that such strategies can cause consumers to become suspicious of the offer and may avoid making the purchase altogether. The researchers conducted three experiments consisting of 662 subjects, with the objective of better understanding consumer behavior, their perception and their attitude in relation to these low price guarantees.

"This research has significant implications for retailers but also for manufacturers," said Adilson Borges, head of the Value & Persuasion Research Center at RMS, in a news release.

"If the offer seems too good to be true, the consumer may start to believe that there is a catch, and become wary or suspicious of the details. This bad image creates a negative effect. The offer must appear to be credible. It must be truly beneficial and financially interesting for the consumer," Borges said.

A price guarantee offering an automatic refund of the difference where the retailer is constantly surveying competitors' pricing works well and gives a positive image of the seller to the consumers. However, an automatic guarantee with a reimbursement that is too high, such as five or ten times the difference, engenders a caution from the consumer, and conveys a rather negative image. Consumers were observed to reduce their purchase intention when facing these types of deals.

"In fact, when we examine the retailers together, we observe that their objective is to give the impression that they have the most competitive offer in the market. From this point of view they have every interest in offering a guarantee of the best price and reimbursing the difference," said Borges.

We've updated our Privacy Policy. Read the updated policy →

PR Biz Update PR Agency News PR People Marketing Trends
No Preview
Powerhouse Public Relations Hires Jessica Lee as Social Media Coordinator

Powerhouse Public Relations, a creative agency providing a wide range of media...

No Preview
PebblePost Appoints 72andSunny's Marita Scarfi as CFO 

PebblePost, the inventor of Programmatic Direct Mail, announced the appointment of...

No Preview
Karyn Martin Named Partner at 451 Marketing

451 Marketing has expanded its executive leadership team to include its...

Thought Leaders On Deadline
Pr, Marketing, Public relations, Social Engagement, PR campaign, PR Measurement, campaign measurement, campaign effectiveness, brand mentions, Taral Patel, PRmention, campaign impact, keyword rankings, social shares
10 Methods to Measure the Impact of PR Campaign

By Taral Patel, PR Executive, PRmention Whenever a company runs a PR...

Pr, Marketing, Public relations, PR writing, PR quotes, spray and pray, PR pet peeves, Ed James, Anthemic Agency PR, PR bad habits, PR bad practices
Cut it Out, Already: 4 Things PR Pros Need to Stop Doing Right Now

By Ed James, President, Anthemic Agency PR Having been in the PR world...

Pr, Marketing, Public relations, Super Bowl, PR industry, PR agency, PR leadership, PR team, Goodman Media, comms lessons, PR MVP, PR coaching, PR rookie
Super Bowl Comms Lessons: Putting Together an All-Star PR Team

By Goodman Media Earlier this month, we watched two standout teams—which...

<-- Google Analytics -->