Poynter's Romenesko Resigns On Heels Of Coverage Controversies: Editor Questioned Journalism Blogger's Methods — Although, Romenesko's Plans To Launch His Own Competing Site May Be a Factor In Public Discrediting

After his editor posted a column questioning his journalistic standards, Poynter‘s pioneering media blogger Jim Romenesko has resigned from his job. The author of the morning go-to blog for thousands of journalists and communications pros quit Thursday after his editor Julie Moos publicly questioned whether he was giving proper attribution to the news sources mentioned in his daily posts. In her column Thursday, Moos criticized Romenesko for not properly disclosing in his synopses that he was using the same language used by the source reporters in the original articles he was citing. "Though information sources have always been displayed prominently in Jim’s posts and are always linked at least once (often multiple times), too many of those posts also included the original author’s verbatim language without containing his or her words in quotation marks, as they should have," Moos wrote in the critical column. Journalists, ironically, reacted rather negatively to the column, according to the post’s comments — the same journalists allegedly victimized by Romenesko’s practice, according to Moos. The majority of commenters suggested that the blogger’s method was clear and transparent — that his descriptions of his coverage often came directly from the source materials. Although his contract with Poynter comes up in just six weeks, Romenesko said that he "thought it was best to leave Poynter after these ‘imperfect attribution’ charges were leveled against me. My heart was no longer in the job," he said, the Washington Post reports. But there’s certainly more to this story — coincidentally, Romenesko has plans to start a new site, JimRomenesko.com, next month, which would compete directly with Poynter, especially when it comes to journalism-related advertising. "I wondered if they were trying to discredit me so advertisers wouldn’t touch me," Romenesko said in an email to the Post. "I have no evidence, though, that that was their motivation," he clarified, according to the Post report.

Since starting his blog in 1999, Romenesko has put together a comprehensive list of articles about newspapers, TV news, news websites and media personalities, as well as broader journalism issues. His method has historically been to create a synopsis of each story with a headline that linked to the original source material. Poynter first raised its concerns last week after the Columbia Journalism Review questioned Moos about Romenesko’s blog for an article. Although some traditional journalists believe that bloggers should never use another writer’s words without clearly using quotation marks, none had not publicly complained about the manner in which Romenesko cited their work in his blog, the Post reports.

In an email to the Post, Moos said she did speak with Romenesko about the advertising issue before his resignation, but that any conflict had been "resolved" before he resigned. She made no mention of those advertising issues in her column, and said Poynter won’t place any restrictions on Romenesko as he seeks advertising for his new site, reports Post writer Paul Farhi.

We've updated our Privacy Policy. Read the updated policy →

PR Biz Update PR Agency News PR People Marketing Trends
acquisition channels, customer acquisition, Digital marketing, Email marketing, Forrester, Marketing, marketing budgets, marketing investments, Mobile marketing, National Retail Federation, paid search, Pr, Public relations, Social media
Facebook Leads Digital Marketing Spend for Retailers as Social & Mobile Budgets Expand, New NRF Study Finds

Paid search and email marketing lead retailers’ lists of effective customer...

Change management, engagement strategy, management initiatives, management/employee disconnect, Marketing, organizational alignment, POPin, Pr, Public relations, Senior management, teambuilding challenges
Teambuilding Challenges: Most Companies Struggle with Lack of Organizational Alignment, Inability to Manage Change

According to a new survey of CIOs and technology execs from...

Shopping cart full of gold gift boxes and red sale sign through laptop monitor concept for e-commerce
Consumer Spend to Reach Highest Level Since Great Recession This Holiday Season—But Stores May Suffer

A Shift from Wish-List Products to Experiences Threatens Brick and Mortar...

Thought Leaders On Deadline
3BL Media, Corporate sustainability, CSR perspectives, Domtar Corporation, Gary Weiland, Marketing, Pr, Public relations, sustainability content, sustainability efforts, Sustainability reporting
CSR Perspectives: Getting Your Company’s Sustainability Efforts Recognized

By Gary Weiland, Strategic Communications Consultant Like many companies, every year...

Can Malay, Marketing, marketing department, marketing execution, marketing industry, marketing measurement, marketing objective, Marketing plan, Marketing strategy, marketing tactics, MediaMiser, Pr, Public relations, strategic execution, SWOT analysis
Strategic Execution: 6 Essential Steps for Developing a Marketing Plan

By Can Malay, MediaMiser Developing annual marketing plans and successfully executing...

AdWords, buying cycle, Clicteq, keyword, Long Tail, long tail keyword, Marketing, PPC marketers, Pr, Public relations, specific keywords, Wesley Parker
Sorry to Burst Your Bubble: The Long Tail Keyword Myth

By Wesley Parker, Founder and CEO, Clicteq  Today’s article is a...