Is It Time To Stop Listening to Social Media?

Posted on the Spin Sucks blog on May 3rd by Elissa Freeman

Shhhh. Can you hear it? It’s the sound of yet another corporate giant falling to its knees after a tidal wave of social media criticism.

Corporate capitulation is happening with frightening regularity these days. We no longer look at the Fortune 500 as impenetrable monoliths; instead, they now appear as dominoes ready to topple at the first flick of public outcry via the Twitterverse.

When do ‘we the people’ stop having a point? And when do we as communicators stop listening to it?

Are we counseling our clients/organizations to respond because it’s the right thing to do or are we being bullied into it via the blogosphere?

Effective social media advocacy campaigns typically start with a like-minded demographic – underlining the ‘strength in numbers’ theory. Mom bloggers first made waves with the makers of Motrin and then took public umbrage at JC Penney’s “I’m too pretty to do homework” T-shirt debacle. In both cases, McNeil Laboratories and JC Penney bowed to the pressure and removed their campaigns.

More recently, the public outcry over the Susan G. Komen Foundation’s anti-Planned Parenthood stance created a unified voice for the undoing of social injustice. Yet, the call for Mars, Inc. to donate proceeds from accelerated sales of Skittles spurred by the Trayvon Martin case falls into the “this is what we think you should do so do it” category.

It appears we may need to start putting a different filter on what constitutes best practices when providing counsel on social media response. Any worthy PR pro will have already integrated social media plans into their client or organizational communications strategy or provided counsel on audience engagement and response.

But is the frequency of public demands via social media creating a ‘cry wolf’ mentality? Just because social media makes water cooler conversation public, how do we gauge the effect it should have on the corporate conscience?

I’ve created a list of thought-starters that I will use as filters the next time I need to provide counsel on a response to a social media outcry.

  1. Consider the demographic. Do they affect my business? Are they an organized entity?
  2. Prevent knee-jerk reactions. Do we need to respond? Now or later?
  3. Implement good crisis communications. The rules still apply depending on the severity of the situation.

Are there any others? How do you judge when and when not to respond?

Elissa Freeman is vice president, PR and communications for the Toronto 2015 Pan/Parapan American Games. You can find her on Twitter @elissapr.

PR Biz Update PR Agency News PR People Marketing Trends
modern devices laptop, smartphone, tablet isolated white background with clipping path
Solving Cross-Device Marketing Challenges: DMA’s ID Project Goes on Tour This Fall with Template RFP and Other Tools

Today’s consumers are increasingly cross-device in their media consumption—and have come...

emerging workforce, growth opportunities, job skills advancement, Marketing, Pr, Public relations, Research Now, Sandy Mazur, skills development, skills gap, Spherion Staffing, worker confidence, workplace trends
Employers and Workers Are Still Struggling to Close the Skills Gap: Study Uncovers Waning Worker Confidence

Despite the red flags raised last year as workers expressed concerns...

audience alienation, awkward brand jokes, brand followers, brand’s social presence, Marketing, marketplace perception, Pr, promotional platform, Public relations, Scott Brandt, social media engagement, social media promotions, Sprout Social
Brands Behaving Badly: New Report Reveals What Many Are Doing to Annoy 60 Percent of People on Social Media

Study Data Finds Most Consumers Are Put Off by Brand Social...

Thought Leaders On Deadline
article categorization, Chantelle Brule, content tagging, content trends, Data analysis, data analysis software, identifying trends, Marketing, media analysis, Media monitoring, MediaMiser, MediaMiser Enterprise, Pr, Public relations, tagging, tagging system
Tagging for Newbies: How to Tag Content for Media Monitoring and Analysis

By Chantelle Brule, Data Analyst, MediaMiser So you want to know...

Abhyudaya Tripathi, buyer’s journey, buyer-centric content, content creation, Content Engagement, Content marketing, content value, Marketing, marketing content, Pr, Public relations, ResultFirst-SEO Services Company
How to Create Buyer-Centric Content that Delivers Real Value

By Abhyudaya Tripathi, Associate Director, ResultFirst-SEO Services Company “Is there anything...

blame and shame, connecting with youth, digital age, digital natives, Kate Gunby, Marketing, marketing to youth, Pr, PRR, PRR Research, Public relations, teen culture, teen marketing, teen parents
How to Talk to Teens: 5 Lessons for Connecting with Today’s Youth

By Kate Gunby, Senior Research Associate, PRR Any PR company knows...