Disconnect Between CMOs and CIOs Threatens Marketing Effectiveness of Companies, New Accenture Study Finds—Only 10 Percent of Top Marketing and IT Execs Believe Collaboration is Sufficient

A disconnect between chief marketing officers and chief information officers threatens the ability of companies to deliver effective customer experiences, according to a new study by Accenture. The study, based on a survey of 400 senior marketing and 250 IT executives in 10 countries, revealed that only one in 10 of the executives believes collaboration between CMOs and CIOs is currently at the right level.

CIOs appear to be more committed to greater collaboration than CMOs, according to the report, The CMO-CIO Disconnect. More than three out of four CIOs surveyed—77 percent—agree that CMO-CIO alignment is important, compared to 57 percent of CMOs participating in the survey. However, despite CIOs appearing more open to engaging with CMOs, only 45 percent of CIOs say that supporting marketing is near or at the top of their list of priorities.

Regarding the use of technology, CMOs and CIOs agree that technology is essential to marketing and that its primary purpose is to gain access to customer insight and intelligence (60 percent of CMOs and 73 percent of CIOs). But while CMOs claim that gaining customer insight is their number one motivator for collaborating with IT, CIOs rank this tenth on their list of reasons to work together. CIOs’ top motivation for collaborating is to improve the customer experience, which CMOs rank as their third most important motivator.

“The CMO and CIO continue to work in silos, but now more than ever bridging the gap between those two organizations is critical for success. With today’s multichannel consumer seeking highly relevant experiences and with digital and analytics platforms emerging to help companies respond, marketing and IT executives must work more closely together,” said Brian Whipple, global managing director of Accenture Interactive, in a news release. “C-suite decision makers face a variety of challenges when collaborating, ranging from a lack of trust to differing business goals. These issues must be resolved to turn a company’s digital marketing capabilities into a platform for market differentiation, business growth, and profitability.”

Challenged Collaboration in Action

The report reveals that when collaborating on a marketing initiative, neither the marketing executives nor the IT executives come away satisfied. According to the survey, 36 percent of CMOs say that IT deliverables fall short of the desired outcome, and 46 percent of CIOs say marketing does not provide an adequate level of detail to meet business requirements.

The survey also shows that a disagreement over the freedom and control of the use of technology and data also prevents effective collaboration. While 45 percent of CMOs say they want to enable their teams to leverage and optimize data and content without IT intervention, 49 percent of CIOs counter that marketing uses technologies without consideration for IT standards.

A Positive Shift

Despite the issues in collaboration raised by the survey, both CMOs and CIOs believe their relationship has improved over the past year: 45 percent of marketing executives and 47 percent of IT executives share this opinion. Additionally, almost an equal number of CMOs (41 percent) and CIOs (42 percent) believe that significantly more collaboration with each other will be required to drive relevant customer experiences.

Steps to Improve CMO-CIO Collaboration

According to the Accenture report, CMOs and CIOs should consider taking the following actions to strengthen their alignment and improve collaboration:

  • The CMO should be identified as the Chief Experience Officer and IT should be looked at as a strategic partner with marketing and not just as a platform provider.
  • The skills mix in both organizations should be updated whereby the marketing department would become more tech savvy and the IT organization would become more agile and responsive to market demands.
  • Both teams should agree on key business levers and embrace tools, processes and platforms to understand consumer intent and unlock consumer value.

“To succeed in the digital age, CMOs must place an immediate focus on technology to improve relevant customer experiences and advance marketing practices,” Whipple said. “The good news is that CMOs and CIOs agree technology is important. Now they must work together to agree on how technology can be most appropriately applied to drive their company’s specific marketing needs, and how it can ultimately result in increased brand affinity, loyalty and sales growth.”

Learn more at: The CMO-CIO Disconnect.

The 2012 CMO-CIO Insights Survey is a global survey sponsored by Accenture aimed at understanding the opinions, challenges and points of view of senior and IT executives as it relates to marketing-IT alignment. The results are based on 405 surveys across 10 countries with senior marketing executives, and 252 surveys across the same countries with IT Executives using the same criteria. All respondents are from companies from the U.S., Canada, Germany, Italy, U.K. and China with at least $1 billion in annual revenues, with companies in France, Australia, Singapore and Brazil all having an annual revenue of at least $500 million. Accenture conducted an online survey in August and September of 2012.

Edited by Richard Carufel

We've updated our Privacy Policy. Read the updated policy →

PR Biz Update PR Agency News PR People Marketing Trends
Ann Sung Ruckstuhl, Harris Poll, independent vendors, Internet annoyances, Marketing, performance analytics, Pr, Public relations, SOASTA, third-party ads, third-party advertising, third-party news, third-party videos
When It Comes to Web Surfing, Americans Say Three’s a Crowd: 85% Say Third-Party Advertising Is Annoying

Performance analytics firm SOASTA recently announced the findings of its Third-Party...

2008 financial crisis, brand reputation, Doug Hesney, Financial crisis, financial recovery, Financial Services Companies, Investor relations, Makovsky, Marketing, Pr, Public relations, reputational issues, Wall Street reputation
Guilty by PR Association: 86% of Financial Services Pros Say 2008 Meltdown Still Impacts Their Company’s Reputation

Nearly One Third of U.S. Consumers Say They Have Lost Trust...

Apple Watch, consumer loyalty, consumer preference, First Insight, Garmin smartwatch, Marketing, Pr, product success, Public relations, smartwatch craze, smartwatch issues, smartwatch manufacturers, smartwatch problems
The Harsh Reality Facing Smartwatch Manufacturers—Consumers Aren’t Likely to Bite Unless Issues Are Addressed

The smartwatch craze that overtook the media and consumer imaginations in...

Thought Leaders On Deadline
Alexa Lemzy, brand marketing, Email marketing, Marketing, marketing budgets, marketing channels, marketing priorities, mobile integration, Mobile marketing, Pr, Public relations, SMS marketing, text marketing, TextMagic
Marketers Need to Make SMS and Email Play Nice Together—Here’s Why And How

By Alexa Lemzy, Customer Support & Content Manager, TextMagic Mobile is...

client relationships, communications messaging, communications relationships, Gotham PR, internal relationships, Lindsay Cosner, Marketing, Pr, PR ingenuity, Public relations, startup communications
The Two Pillars of Successful Startup Communications

By Lindsay Cosner, Account Supervisor, Gotham PR One might say we...

business pain points, campaign budget, client differentiation, client relationships, Marketing, MediaMiser, Pr, PR client, PR process, PR pros, project budget, project deadlines, Public relations, Target audience, Whitney Zelmer
8 Crucial Questions Every PR Pro Needs to Ask Their Client Before Getting Started

By Whitney Zelmer, Award & Marketing Coordinator, Bulldog Reporter You’ve reached...