Deceptive Sunscreen Marketing In the PR Spotlight: Despite New FDA Labeling Mandates, Many Brands Continue to Flaunt Misleading SPF Ratings That Give Consumers False Sense of Security

Sunbathers headed to the beach this summer will find new sunscreen labels on store shelves that are designed to make the products more effective and easier to use. But despite those long-awaited changes, many sunscreens continue to carry SPF ratings that some experts consider misleading and potentially dangerous, according to a consumer watchdog group.

A survey of 1,400 sunscreen products by the Environmental Working Group finds that most products meet new federal requirements put in place last December. The rules from the Food and Drug Administration ban terms like "waterproof," which regulators consider misleading, and require that sunscreens filter out both ultraviolet A and B rays. Previously some products only blocked UVB rays, which cause most sunburn, while providing little protection against UVA rays that pose the greatest risk of skin cancer and wrinkles, an AP news release reports.

Despite that broader protection, one in seven products reviewed by the watchdog group boasted sun protection factor, or SPF, ratings above 50, which have long been viewed with skepticism by experts. In part, that’s because SPF numbers like 100 or 150 can give users a false sense of security, leading them to stay in the sun long after the lotion has stopped protecting their skin, reports the news release by AP writer Matthew Perrone.

Many consumers assume that SPF 100 is twice as effective as SPF 50, but dermatologists say the difference between the two is actually negligible. Where an SPF 50 product might protect against 97 percent of sunburn-causing rays, an SPF 100 product might block 98.5 percent of those rays.

"The high SPF numbers are just a gimmick," said Marianne Berwick, professor of epidemiology at the University of New Mexico, in a news release. "Most people really don’t need more than an SPF 30 and they should reapply it every couple of hours." Berwick says sunscreen should be used in combination with hats, clothing and shade, which provide better protection against ultraviolet radiation.

Some dermatologists say there may be some rationale for using higher SPF sunscreens, since users often don’t apply enough of the lotion to get its full effect.

"The challenge is that beyond 50, the increase in UV protection is relatively small," says Dr. Henry Lim, chair of dermatology at the Henry Ford Hospital in Detroit.

The FDA itself said in 2011 that "labeling a product with a specific SPF value higher than 50 would be misleading to the consumer." At the time the agency proposed capping all SPF values at 50 because "there is not sufficient data to show that products with SPF values higher than 50 provide greater protection for users." But regulators have faced pushback from companies, including Johnson & Johnson, which argue that higher SPF products provide measurable benefits.

As a result, the FDA says it is still reviewing studies and comments submitted by outside parties, and there is no deadline for the agency to finalize an SPF cap.

It took the agency decades to put in place last year’s sunscreen changes. FDA first announced its intent to draft sunscreen rules in 1978 and published them in 1999. The agency then delayed finalizing the regulations for years until it could address concerns from both industry and consumers.

One Response

  1. Anonymous May 22, 2013 Reply

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Marketing Trends PR Agency News PR Biz Update PR People
Silhouette of businessman sit on chair and hold a cigar and looking at the city in night.
Targeting Insights: Retail Growth Is Online, and the Wealthy Are the Big Spenders—So Engaging Affluents Online Is a Win-Win

What kinds of online experiences do today’s affluent consumers—and tomorrow’s—want? A...

Office life: business team during a meeting
Broken Engagement: New Academic Study Says Nearly Three Fourths of U.S. Workers in Their 30s Want a Career Change

A majority of U.S. working adults want to change careers, but...

school stationary
Consumers Decide that 2015 Back-to-School Shopping Can Wait, Deloitte Study Finds: Shopping Will Be Spread Throughout the Year

With plenty of last year’s supplies stowed in the closet and...

On Deadline Thought Leaders
Is Data Driving Your Leadership Decisions? Eight Ways Customer Analytics Can Give Your Company a Competitive Edge

In the spotlight: Jeff Sauro, Founding Principal, MeasuringU In a global...

Ally Mann
SeaWorld’s Huge PR Challenge: New Campaign Aims for Transparency—But Has This Fish Been Out of Water Too Long?

By Ally Mann, Freelance Writer SeaWorld has been desperately trying to...

Drew Bernard
Cater to Your Audience’s Sense of Social Self for Optimal Results

By Drew Bernard, Founder and CEO, ActionSprout.com As more and more...

Media monitoring and analysis

Current clients, please login here. Would you like to reduce the...

Inside Health Media

Current clients, please login here. Top pharmaceutical companies, hospitals, healthcare PR...

MediaPro: Bulldog Reporter's media database

Current clients, please login here. Do you need precisely targeted press...