October 30, 2014
Subscribe to the Daily 'Dog

January 17, 2013

PR Ethics and Reputation: PR Professionals Are Not "Yes Men" When Pressured to Be Unethical, New Baylor Study Finds

Public relations professionals who have provided ethics counsel to senior management are at least as fervent about serving the public interest — sometimes even more so — as they are about their duty to their organizations, according to a Baylor University researcher.

A new study of 30 senior public relations professionals, most of whom had served as an "organizational conscience," showed the individuals viewed themselves as an "independent voice" in the organization and not "mired by its perspective or politics," said study author Marlene S. Neill, Ph.D., a lecturer in the department of journalism, public relations and new media in Baylor's College of Arts & Sciences.

The study, published in Journal of Mass Media Ethics: Exploring Questions of Media Morality, was co-authored by Minette Drumwright, Ph.D., an associate professor of advertising at the University of Texas at Austin, and may be viewed here.

Researchers did in-depth interviews with senior public relations professionals in the United States and Australia, with an average of 27 years of experience. All but three had served as the chief public relations officers in their organizations, which included corporations, nonprofit organizations and government entities; and two of those also provided counsel in their roles in PR agencies for their clients as external counselors.

Study participants said they often were in the "kill the messenger" predicament, making it tricky to give criticism to people who outranked them and to persuade those people to agree with them, Neill said.

Speaking up on sensitive ethical issues required courage, study participants said. A few were fired or demoted for refusing to do something that was blatantly unethical; two resigned when their advice was rejected, including one who refused to include false information in a press release.

One participant noted that "I can't afford to lose my credibility … As PR professionals, it's all we have. And if I lose my credibility here, it's not like I can just go start over with someone else, somewhere else."

One individual said that the "'yes man' has no value, no value whatsoever" in PR. Another said one reason for her good relationship with her company CEO is that "he can count on me to not always agree with him."

Another major barrier was a common misperception among senior executives that public relations is nothing more than a tool of marketing, which limits PR professionals' roles as problem solvers.

Crucial to their jobs is a sound relationship with their organizations' legal counsels, informants said. So is access to key decision makers, the better to ensure "fire prevention" instead of "fire fighting" — damage control in a crisis.

Neill said that participants were resourceful about how to communicate to management without seeming judgmental, using such approaches as mock news conferences and the "headline test," in which managers were asked to imagine a good headline and a bad headline that might result from an approach they advocated.

One participant contrasted her experience at an iron-fisted company — in which senior managers' attitude was one of, "Do what I say, and don't question me" — with a more effective and positive experience at another company. There, she said, "Nobody is belittled; the managers and executives don't feel like you're questioning their authority. They're very much into a learning mode. They ask a lot of questions; they very much are information gathering."

Comments

PR Ethics

I appreciate your write-up. I have one key question: If unethical actions were ingrained in corporate culture, what method(s) would you use to change organizational behavior, beginning with senior management without being judgmental?

Communication Problems

Great study. The fear of loosing credibility is a problem I have encountered on a personal level. Point taken on communicating with management. Certain publications have taken on to address ethics content creation.

Really great post, Thank you

Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up! desain website surabaya

Thanks for writing such a

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing... charity auto auction

Easily, the doctrine is

Easily, the doctrine is indeed the cream text on this registry allied outcome. I strong in accompanying your outcomes further resolution eagerly ogle progressive to your adjacent modernizes. True maxim blesss mind nay proper be adequate, for the fantasti c lucidity in your paper. I devise instantaneously capture your rss nurse to visit knowing of some restores. martial arts mesa az

I have recently started a

I have recently started a blog, the info you provide on this site has helped me greatly. Thanks  for all of your time & work.   Forum

Hey – fantastic blog,

Hey – fantastic blog, impartial looking near several blogs, appears a truly pleasant pallet you are wearing. I’m currently wearing WordPress for a limited of my blogs however looking to amend digit of them atop to a podium analogous to yours as a hardship score. Anything in individual you would suggest about it? True local

I thought it was going to be

I thought it was going to be several wearisome experienced courier, however it truly compensated for my tour. I mind dispatch a join to this messenger on my blog. I am unfailing my tourists desire discover that truly helpful. https://youtube.com/watch?v=T9CJTsEa4ys

I must tell, I mind this was

I must tell, I mind this was a nice remarkable foretell whereas it occurs to this issue. Loved the data. . . https://youtube.com/watch?v=T9CJTsEa4ys

Lovely estimable courier. I

Lovely estimable courier. I purely stumbled atop your blog besides liked to answer that I get very liked lesson your blog notify. Some road I’ll be subscribing to your fatten plus I longing you dispatch encore directly. tampa fishing

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Type the characters you see in this picture. (verify using audio)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.